Standing up may unmask cognitive deficits in Parkinson's disease patients

Al Saint Jacques, MDLinx | December 01, 2016

A new study shows that when patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) experience a drop in blood pressure upon standing up – a condition known as orthostatic hypotension (OH) – they exhibit significant cognitive deficits. These deficits reverse when they lie down and their blood pressure returns to normal, according to results of a study published online in the journal Neurology.


“In this study, we demonstrated that the upright posture in patients with Parkinson’s disease exacerbated cognitive deficits, and that this effect is transient and reversible.

These cognitive impairments may go unnoticed by physicians assessing patients with PD who are lying down or seated, and could lead to difficulty in daily activities performed while standing and walking, such as tracking conversations, counting change, and interpreting traffic signals, explained researchers led by neurologists at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) and neuropsychologists at Boston University.

“Cognitive impairment is a common symptom of Parkinson’s disease,” said co-senior author Roy Freeman, MD, director of the Center for Autonomic and Peripheral Nerve Disorders at BIDMC and a professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School (HMS). “In this study, we demonstrated that the upright posture in patients with Parkinson’s disease exacerbated cognitive deficits, and that this effect is transient and reversible. Based on these results, we encourage clinicians to include cognitive testing in a variety of postures in their assessments of patients.”

PD is a progressive degeneration of parts of the nervous system marked by characteristic tremor, rigidity, and slowness of movement. It affects many aspects of movement and can cause a masklike, expressionless face, rigid limbs, and problems with walking and posture. PD is also associated with cognitive defects attributed to breakdowns in connectivity between regions of the brain. Up to half of all people with PD may also have orthostatic hypotension.

In a previous study, Freeman and coworkers demonstrated that orthostatic hypotension is linked to reversible cognitive impairment in patients with a rare neurological disorder called autoimmune autonomic ganglionopathy. In this new study of the far more prevalent PD, the researchers investigated whether OH is linked to reversible cognitive deficits in patients with PD as well.

Freeman and colleagues including lead author Justin Centi and co-senior author Alice Cronin-Golomb, PhD, director of the Vision and Cognition Laboratory and Center for Clinical Biopsychology and a professor of psychological and brain sciences at Boston University, divided 55 volunteers into three study groups. One group consisted of 18 patients with both PD and OH; another group of 19 patients had PD but without OH; and the third group was made up of 18 control participants with neither PD nor OH. All participants were given a series of cognitive tests, with the tests administered while supine and again while tilted to 60 degrees. Researchers measured and recorded the participants’ blood pressure before and during each round of cognitive testing to ensure that participants were never at risk for fainting.

“As we suspected, people with both Parkinson’s disease and orthostatic hypotension showed posture-related impairments when upright relative to supine on nearly all measures of cognition,” said Centi, who noted that study participants with PD without orthostatic hypotension demonstrated deficits on only two cognitive tests. No difference was seen between upright and supine scores for the control group.

When the three groups’ relative performances were compared to each other, postural changes had no significant impact on participants with PD but without OH, compared with the control group. However, participants with PD and OH were far more susceptible to posture-related impairment on several tests, including those that measured math skills, the ability to produce words easily, keeping information in mind while working on it, paying sufficient attention so that later memory is efficient, and searching for items quickly and accurately.

“Essentially all neuropsychological tests are given to patients in the seated position in the clinic as well as during most research studies – with the exception of imaging studies in which the patient is lying down,” said Cronin-Golomb. “The cognitive performance that we see in those patients with Parkinson’s disease who are tested when seated or lying down in fact may underestimate their cognitive problems in real life, when they are standing up and going about their business of daily activities. Also, the patterns of brain activity that we see on imaging when they are lying down may not be the patterns that the brain produces during normal upright activity.”

Cognitive deficits in PD result, at least in part, from neurodegeneration, the authors explained. But transient blood pressure changes when upright may indeed play a contributing role. Clinical providers might miss an important target for intervention when not considering OH as a contributor to cognitive impairment.

In addition to Freeman, Centi, and Cronin-Golomb, study coauthors included Christopher H. Gibbons, MD, of BIDMC and HMS; Sandy Neargarder, PhD, of Boston University and Bridgewater State University; and Alex Canova of Boston University.

This work was funded by grants from the National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (R01NS067128) and support from a Ruth L. Kirschstein National Research Service Award (F31NS074801).